ProductsResearchResultsPricingCompanyLoginSTART FREE
← All case studies
Case Study · Live · April 2026
+217.3%
More engaged leads vs equal-split testing

Apex Overlay — Our Own Campaign

B2B SaaS · Cold email acquisition · 3 email variants · Live
01 / Setup

We used Apex Overlay to run our own cold outreach — targeting agency founders and Instantly power users for beta access. Three email variants, one list, same sending schedule. The product optimising its own acquisition.

02 / The Shift
“instantly reply rates” 80.4%
“client campaigns” 9.8%
“your instantly campaigns” 9.8%
33%
Day 1 start
9.8%
Day 2 · bad variant caught
80.4%
Day 3+ · winner locked
03 / Results
80.4%
Sends to winning variant
Engine routed 4 out of 5 sends to the best email automatically
4.3%
Reply rate on best variant
Suppressed variants sat at 1.2% and below
<24h
To contain the bad variant
Throttled to 9.8% before we saw the negative replies
04 / Insight
A bad variant was generating unsubscribe requests. The engine throttled it to 9.8% before I even saw the replies in my inbox.
Caius Seemann · Founder, Apex-Scale
05 / Why it matters
  • A bad variant doesn’t just waste sends. It damages your sender reputation, triggers spam reports, and makes your next campaign harder to land in the inbox. At 24 emails a day this saved roughly 5 leads from a variant that was actively hurting deliverability. At 500 a day that’s a domain reputation problem.
  • Instantly kills all but one variant overnight. That sudden shift from three email patterns to one is exactly what spam filters flag. Apex Overlay throttles gradually — keeping the sending pattern diverse enough to protect deliverability.

Stop sending your best leads your worst email.

Connect your Instantly account, click Optimize on one campaign, and see sends start shifting to your best email within your first 50 sends. The Freemium plan is available this month — connect now and it’s yours free forever. No card needed.

Freemium plan · Connects to Instantly.ai in under 2 minutes
More results